"Everywhere I went people told me that they were deeply worried about the future of democracy. The felt alianted from both the electoral process, and the culture wars and that were grouping about for plain language in which to express their discontent"
Is this why we don't "pay attention"? Have we become so disconnected that we no longer understand what is going on around us? Is it possible to understand the modern world of politics. I think this is why a lot of people don't participate or care about the government as much any more; it's simply because they don't understand. I have to say, I feel their pain. It's like when I sometimes pick up an abandon paper at breakfast and start reading the front page articles. They would make so much more sense if I had a better grasp on what was going on. It's really hard to do something like pick up a newspaper or vote in an election and really understand what is going on and what is being said when you have been neglectful for so long.
In the case of politics I think a lot of people would like to blame all the red tape, the bureaucracy, and the politics of the status quo instead of themselves. However, I don't think it's fair to blame it on the system. Politics have always been complicated and controversial and people still managed to get a grasp on what was going on and participate in government and community affairs.
Maybe we're just not as ambitious. Or maybe we've just gotten lazy.
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
Monday, March 14, 2011
The Winky Smiley Face vs Japan
After reading Bellah's article I can't help to wonder how distracted we truly are. I couldn't help to wonder about that this weekend.
There is distraction in the sense I had a really hard time getting anything done this weekend. Everything else just seemed to much more interesting than my French homework. That might just be procrastination.
Then there's distraction in the sense of just not really paying attention. Like millions of others around the world, I've been keeping my eyes on the headlines on Japan. I'm watching but I'm not doing anything. Not even talking about it with my friends. Instead we spent a long lunch on Sunday talking about the implications and the usage of the winky smiley face on Facebook chat. Don't get me wrong, it was a fun conversation but can it be used to exemplify how distracted we really are?
There is distraction in the sense I had a really hard time getting anything done this weekend. Everything else just seemed to much more interesting than my French homework. That might just be procrastination.
Then there's distraction in the sense of just not really paying attention. Like millions of others around the world, I've been keeping my eyes on the headlines on Japan. I'm watching but I'm not doing anything. Not even talking about it with my friends. Instead we spent a long lunch on Sunday talking about the implications and the usage of the winky smiley face on Facebook chat. Don't get me wrong, it was a fun conversation but can it be used to exemplify how distracted we really are?
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Families
I loved the points Bellah makes about families, about the importance of them and the ambiguity as well.
Being the daughter of a social worker who works in family social services (as well has being a social work major myself), I've been raised on the importance of relying on your family, being there for your family, and, just like Bellah talks about, eating with them. I think he was spot on when he said attentive families breed attentive children. It goes right back to de Tocqueville and the development of habits. If we form good habits of attention in our families we can not only improve our private lives (such as in marriages) but also our public lives (i.e. volunteering and joining organizations).
This class may be called "democratic vistas" but I think the underlying theme of the class may truly be "get involved and stay involved". De Tocqueville presented this in a very formal manner based in our government and Bellah and Putman have kind of joined forces to advocate for personalized involvement. By personalized involvement I mean finding an association you can be passionate about and that inserts you if governmental affairs isn't your cup of tea.
Circling back to the idea Bellah presents on families (I know, this is very disorganized and I feel like most of my blog posts are. I should work on that but I'm just so focused on getting my thoughts down before they vanish), I was able to connect his claim that creating "normal standard" for families is a historical mistake to one of my other classes.
Currently, I'm enrolled in Courtly Love in the Middle Ages and last week one of our readings had to do with day to day life in medieval times. One section the book talked about focused specifically on the ambiguity of "families" at the time. Medieval France didn't even have a real name for what we think of as family (which, in the case of my history textbook was blood relatives who live with you). They didn't have name because the word they used, familia, refereed to everybody who lived in that household; blood relations and hired help alike. To make things even more complicated, children, especially boys, rarely lived with their real parents. They often went to live with the maternal uncles or religious institutions (usually by the time they were 8) to receive their education. I think this goes to show us that it's awfully hard to have a standard now when at any point of time in history there wasn't one to be had.
Being the daughter of a social worker who works in family social services (as well has being a social work major myself), I've been raised on the importance of relying on your family, being there for your family, and, just like Bellah talks about, eating with them. I think he was spot on when he said attentive families breed attentive children. It goes right back to de Tocqueville and the development of habits. If we form good habits of attention in our families we can not only improve our private lives (such as in marriages) but also our public lives (i.e. volunteering and joining organizations).
This class may be called "democratic vistas" but I think the underlying theme of the class may truly be "get involved and stay involved". De Tocqueville presented this in a very formal manner based in our government and Bellah and Putman have kind of joined forces to advocate for personalized involvement. By personalized involvement I mean finding an association you can be passionate about and that inserts you if governmental affairs isn't your cup of tea.
Circling back to the idea Bellah presents on families (I know, this is very disorganized and I feel like most of my blog posts are. I should work on that but I'm just so focused on getting my thoughts down before they vanish), I was able to connect his claim that creating "normal standard" for families is a historical mistake to one of my other classes.
Currently, I'm enrolled in Courtly Love in the Middle Ages and last week one of our readings had to do with day to day life in medieval times. One section the book talked about focused specifically on the ambiguity of "families" at the time. Medieval France didn't even have a real name for what we think of as family (which, in the case of my history textbook was blood relatives who live with you). They didn't have name because the word they used, familia, refereed to everybody who lived in that household; blood relations and hired help alike. To make things even more complicated, children, especially boys, rarely lived with their real parents. They often went to live with the maternal uncles or religious institutions (usually by the time they were 8) to receive their education. I think this goes to show us that it's awfully hard to have a standard now when at any point of time in history there wasn't one to be had.
Tuesday, March 8, 2011
Response to Putnam
Mark Chaves from the sociology department at the University of Arizona spends most of his article "Are We 'Bowling Alone'--and Does it Matter" agreeing with Putman but he does so in a rather roundabout way.
He acknowledges the fact that the numbers do show a decline in civic engagement over the years. However, he says it's more of a shift than a decline. He says to look at examples like churches. They're official membership is in decline but the number of people who par take in activities such as small groups have increased.
He primarily blames the shift in civic engagement primarily on a shift in generations. Today's youth simply aren't involved enough. Without this development of habit at an early age (yay de Tocquevielle!, they are less likely to become engaged in civic activities as adults.
Chaves other reasons civic engagement has declined or shifted: television watching, suburbanization and pressures of time and money. He never fully explains TV as the culprit but we can only guess: TV stops people from getting out and doing stuff. Suburbanization creates commuting time which prevents people from being involved in activities they may be interested in. Pressures of time and money doesn't really need to be explained. We simply are overcome by the need to work and earn a living that things such as volunteering (and sleeping and eating if you're talking to a college student)are the first "extras" to go.
All together, between Putman and Chaves, these articles made me want to get up and do something. I was really active and involved in several volunteer organizations in high school but since coming to college I haven't find my "niche" and these articles made me want to get out and find it quick. I miss being involved.
One more interesting comment Putman made that Chaves points out, is that evidence alone is not enough. Just like we discussed in class on Monday, alone, individuals are weak but associations together are strong. One piece of evidence is find and dandy and a fun trivia fact, but in order to prove a point you need a whole array of interconnected pieces of evidence.
He acknowledges the fact that the numbers do show a decline in civic engagement over the years. However, he says it's more of a shift than a decline. He says to look at examples like churches. They're official membership is in decline but the number of people who par take in activities such as small groups have increased.
He primarily blames the shift in civic engagement primarily on a shift in generations. Today's youth simply aren't involved enough. Without this development of habit at an early age (yay de Tocquevielle!, they are less likely to become engaged in civic activities as adults.
Chaves other reasons civic engagement has declined or shifted: television watching, suburbanization and pressures of time and money. He never fully explains TV as the culprit but we can only guess: TV stops people from getting out and doing stuff. Suburbanization creates commuting time which prevents people from being involved in activities they may be interested in. Pressures of time and money doesn't really need to be explained. We simply are overcome by the need to work and earn a living that things such as volunteering (and sleeping and eating if you're talking to a college student)are the first "extras" to go.
All together, between Putman and Chaves, these articles made me want to get up and do something. I was really active and involved in several volunteer organizations in high school but since coming to college I haven't find my "niche" and these articles made me want to get out and find it quick. I miss being involved.
One more interesting comment Putman made that Chaves points out, is that evidence alone is not enough. Just like we discussed in class on Monday, alone, individuals are weak but associations together are strong. One piece of evidence is find and dandy and a fun trivia fact, but in order to prove a point you need a whole array of interconnected pieces of evidence.
Thursday, March 3, 2011
Paper idea
I've been trying to work through some ideas for the paper and this is what I have so far.
De Tocqueville- An outsider looking in. Was looking for the reasons for success so he could pass his findings onto the French.
De Tocqueville was interested in analyzing the ways and reasons for democracy's success in America. His umbrella reasons boil down to laws, mores and habits. Americans have the habit and the belief of working for their own good. Therefore democracy relies on self-interest in the government.
Relating self-interest to the volunteer associations
People join associations because of something that they are motivated by or feel strongly about. Associations work to spread awareness. The most serious associations work to spread awareness in order to make a change. The changes they propose are presented to the government. By lobbying they take an active role in influencing their government to make changes for their personal interest. Ex: The American Colonization Society worked to "relocate" freed slaves to what is now Liberia. The association secured government funding to run the program. Members of the society were mostly citizens who were worried about the repercussions of having free slaves living in America.
I also really want to talk about America's ability to make "retrievable mistakes" but I need to think a little more about integrating that with self interest. Perhaps "mistakes" want to be fixed when the interests of the people change.
De Tocqueville- An outsider looking in. Was looking for the reasons for success so he could pass his findings onto the French.
De Tocqueville was interested in analyzing the ways and reasons for democracy's success in America. His umbrella reasons boil down to laws, mores and habits. Americans have the habit and the belief of working for their own good. Therefore democracy relies on self-interest in the government.
Relating self-interest to the volunteer associations
People join associations because of something that they are motivated by or feel strongly about. Associations work to spread awareness. The most serious associations work to spread awareness in order to make a change. The changes they propose are presented to the government. By lobbying they take an active role in influencing their government to make changes for their personal interest. Ex: The American Colonization Society worked to "relocate" freed slaves to what is now Liberia. The association secured government funding to run the program. Members of the society were mostly citizens who were worried about the repercussions of having free slaves living in America.
I also really want to talk about America's ability to make "retrievable mistakes" but I need to think a little more about integrating that with self interest. Perhaps "mistakes" want to be fixed when the interests of the people change.
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
America's awkward place
Tonight I went to the PAC's panel discussion on the revolts in the Arab world. For a while there it was more like I was sitting in AmCon again. One of the professors (I wish I knew what her name was) talked a lot about how democracy is playing a role in the protests and how its going to pan out in the next several years as the revolted countries try to implement a democratic system. One of her last points, and the one I think stands out the most, was her comment on how America has put it's self in a very awkward place. On one hand they want to encourage democracy in other countries, but at the same time they need to stay out in order to let the country develop democracy by it's own standards. De Tocqueville would describe it as allowing the people of the country to develop self interest in their government. America can't come in and set up the government because they would never be able to cater to the needs of the country as they see it. On the other hand, if America doesn't step in and help move the Arab world towards democracy, its almost like we're turning our back on democracy.
I wonder how de Tocqueville would comment on America's position. One of the goals for writing his book was to demonstrate to the French people why and how democracy worked in America but he also pleads the case for self interest in the government. Perhaps he intended his book to be more of a personal commentary than a guide.
I wonder how de Tocqueville would comment on America's position. One of the goals for writing his book was to demonstrate to the French people why and how democracy worked in America but he also pleads the case for self interest in the government. Perhaps he intended his book to be more of a personal commentary than a guide.
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Another post on de Tocqueville and I can't come up with a title
"it is our inexperience of liberty in action which leads us to regard freedom of association as no more than a right to make war on the government"
This is an idea we kind of talked about in class. It's one of the reasons democracy was able to take root in America; we were already use to the idea of freedom of association. It's something that is now (and was then) so natural to us (even de Tocqueville described it as a "natural right")that we don't even think about using it as a tool of destruction. We get together and talk about our politics and laws and we needs to be changed and what doesn't and through our democratic system make those changes that we feel need to be made. Because in America it's such an everyday happening, you don't realize that other people in the world use it to take down their government, not aid it along in it's natural process. These past few weeks in the Middle East and northern Africa could be no better example of this and I'm very intereseted to see what happens later down the road in these countries.
I wonder what de Tocqueville would have to say about all of it.
This is an idea we kind of talked about in class. It's one of the reasons democracy was able to take root in America; we were already use to the idea of freedom of association. It's something that is now (and was then) so natural to us (even de Tocqueville described it as a "natural right")that we don't even think about using it as a tool of destruction. We get together and talk about our politics and laws and we needs to be changed and what doesn't and through our democratic system make those changes that we feel need to be made. Because in America it's such an everyday happening, you don't realize that other people in the world use it to take down their government, not aid it along in it's natural process. These past few weeks in the Middle East and northern Africa could be no better example of this and I'm very intereseted to see what happens later down the road in these countries.
I wonder what de Tocqueville would have to say about all of it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)